JeremiahTolbert.com: SF Writer Web Designer Photographer

Posts Tagged ‘submissions’

This Week’s Editoral Advice: Do Not Reply to Rejection Letters

Filed Under: SF Business, SF Podcasting, Writing Advice

This is still happening from time to time with my work for Escape Pod. I had kind of thought by now that arguing with an editor over their comments in a rejection letter was commonly considered a bad idea to be avoided at all costs, but I’m still getting these at Escape Pod. Let me put it to you all straight.

Nothing makes me more disinclined to purchase your work than you arguing with me about me not buying a story.

There are a lot of minor mistakes you can make as a slush writer. I overlook most of them. For instance, we get sent things as attachments when our guidelines call for them to be in the body of an email. I might mention it briefly to the submitter, but I don’t hold it against them much. There are so many differing e-submissions systems that I can understand why this happens. No big deal.

But when you decide to quibble with an editor over the points of his or her rejection letter, you’re crossing a professional line. You are entitled to your opinion. It’s a good thing if you have enough faith in your story that you will continue to send it out, because one editor’s opinion doesn’t amount to much, which is why I say my editorial comments are not intended as writing advice.

The main thing it will lead to is an editor not providing you any detailed feedback at all. We will simply write form rejections for your work from then on out. Because nothing is more annoying to me, at least, than someone deciding to bicker over a rejection. It’s not going to change our minds. It’s only going to make you look worse. So we’ll stop giving you points to quibble with. This is not good for you. We don’t want to do this.

It is a no-win situation for the writer.

So just don’t do it. Stick to creating your editor voodoo dolls and slagging us off to your cats. Take out your frustrations another way, even if the editor is dead wrong. It doesn’t matter.

And another thing– I would rather not see replies, even short thank yous, at all. It clutters up my inbox, which I work very hard to keep organized, and your continuing submissions with us is thanks enough. Tack what you want to say on to the cover letter of your next submission. I would prefer that.

Also, Machine Gun Submissions

Oh, and finally, one last thing– it does you no good to send me story after story after story when I’m reading them quickly, when you get rejected every time. You should cool it and wait a bit between submissions. Probably want to wait and let me forget about how I rejected 3 stories in an hour. Because I do notice, and I know other editors do too, especially with e-submissions at ‘zines with relatively fast turnaround times. Nick Mamatas even had a submissions limit. I’m considering implementing one if this keeps up. At the very least, you’ll stop getting such rapid replies.

|

About Me

Hi! My name is Jeremiah Tolbert, but call me Jeremy. I am a writer, photographer, and web designer currently living in Northern Colorado, seeking either freelance web design work or fulltime employment. Drop me a line if you have any questions, comments, advice, or heckles. I love hearing from new people. If you’re inclined, you can follow me on Twitter, where I share various links and talk about the same things I talk about here, only with fewer characters.

My Best Content

Recent Comments

Previous Photos at Flickr

P3065425

P3065425

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3065414

P3065414

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3065408

P3065408

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3065397

P3065397

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3065370

P3065370

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3065332

P3065332

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045317

P3045317

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045310

P3045310

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045300

P3045300

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045289

P3045289

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045288

P3045288

Olympus digital camera

>>>>

P3045285

P3045285

Olympus digital camera

>>>>


See More Photos at Flickr